Grand Theft Auto 6 feels like playing on a fan-run roleplay server, and I love it

Grand Theft Auto 6 abandons the breakneck pace of GTA Online, and feels much more like the humble RP server

Jason and Lucia from Grand Theft Auto 6 standing on a rooftop above Vice City, each with a weapon in hand.
Image: Rockstar Gmes

You, or someone you know, is probably playing Grand Theft Auto 6 — or at the very least, you’re seeing people react and discuss the game on social media. It’s a big game, and I intend to savor it slowly over the coming months, but there’s something I immediately noticed upon jumping into the game: this shit is slow as hell. That’s a compliment from me, although I can see it frustrating some players. It’s also very interesting because it means Rockstar didn’t take inspiration from the wildly popular Grand Theft Auto Online, but instead from the game’s fan-run roleplay servers.

Obviously, Rockstar is also borrowing from their own past games. There’s a lot taken from Red Dead Redemption 2, like a slower and heavier melee system, a limited weapons loadout, and the slow, manual process of buying goods and eating food. San Andreas had some of the RPG elements, with Carl having the choice to hit the gym to affect his physique. GTA4 has Niko heading out on dates with his romantic interests. It’d be silly to claim that roleplayers invented all the slow and deliberate mechanics in GTA 6 — but the runaway popularity of these servers definitely had an impact on the overall direction.

Roleplay servers, run with the FiveM software, deliberately add layers of tension to the core GTA experience. Players need to manually buckle up and start the engine, and other players take up the role of cops who can stop them for running a red light or speeding down the freeway. You have to manually monitor and take care of your food and drink levels, lest you pass out from dehydration and have to go to the hospital. It’s all very elaborate and life simulation-y, in the service of supporting emergent narratives. 

Jason and Lucia prep for a robbery in the key art for Grand Theft Auto 6
Image: Rockstar Games

I played on one of these servers during the height of COVID lockdowns, and I got super into the spirit of things by playing a corrupt politician with a fashion magazine and crime empire. Rockstar are very aware of the popularity and potential of these servers — so aware, in fact, that they bought the team behind FiveM and RedM back in 2023. I expected this to mostly pay off in Grand Theft Auto Online 2, whenever that arrives. Rockstar played their cards to the chest, so I wasn’t sure how much we’d see these elements show up in 6’s campaign.

Grand Theft Auto Online, on the other hand, is all about instant gratification. Players can accumulate a sprawling list of real estate, from nightclubs to biker club compounds to arcades and submarines and yachts and... It’s all a bit overwhelming, and at this point in GTA Online’s life cycle, a player owns a significant stake in San Andreas. The cops are a non-factor; if they show up, I simply jump into my flying car and jet away. There are some more grounded missions, but it’s all very fast-paced. It’s a playground, not a realistic simulation.

I think this is what is causing the whiplash for some players. If you jump into GTA6 after playing Online, it’s like someone violently slamming the brakes. If you’re a Red Dead Redemption 2 enjoyer, it’s an easier transition. And if you’ve played on GTA roleplay servers, it’s like sliding back into a warm bath.

Jason and Lucia pose on the beach in a piece of promotional art from Grand Theft Auto 6
Image: Rockstar Games

Here’s an example of the pacing: in the very early game, I’m playing as Jason, working for an older guy named Brian in a quiet edge of the state of Leonida, far away from the glitz and glamor of Vice City. I drove around in my beat-up truck, doing a variety of odd jobs. As night fell, Brian gave me a call, and I picked up. It’s pretty common for open-world RPGs to ignore things like time of day or the amount of quests you’ve done in a row. In Cyberpunk 2077, for instance, it’s pretty easy to start a big quest chain and end up doing five or six missions in a row without anyone commenting on the time commitment.

So, I started heading towards the quest marker, only to get a text from Brian. He acknowledged it was late, I had a long day, and suggested I head home and get some rest. So I went home, took a shower, changed into my jammies, and went to bed. Then I woke up, had a protein shake, and headed off to the mission.  This trend continues as I continue to play. Jason does extensive home repairs, goes grocery shopping, gets a haircut, and feeds his landlord’s snake.

It’s an interesting angle to take from a series known for enabling chaos and explosions, but it does a lot to set the stage for the relationship between Jason and Lucia, which is the heart of the game. These are real people, not cartoon characters, and the life simulation elements of the game do a lot to make their dynamic feel real and relatable. I know as I advance into the story, there’ll be much more of the action one expects from a Grand Theft Auto. For now, I’m just marveling at how similar the campaign feels to playing on a roleplay server.