This vampire visual novel can't quite live up to its potential

Oaths and Ashes makse good use of Vampire: The Masquerade's politics, but crumbles under its own complex routes

Alice speaks with Madame Kiez, a blonde woman in a dark dress, in a Berlin brothel in this screenshot from Vampire: The Masquerade: Oaths & Ashes
Image: Revive the Spark

Vampire: the Masquerade began as a tabletop system, but has inspired a wide slate of video games. Some have earned more attention than others — Bloodlines is a RPG classic, and the upcoming Disco Elysium-alike has my attention — but there are tons of smaller gems hidden in the pile. Vampire: The Masquerade: Oaths & Ashes is one of the games that highlights the setting’s strengths, but struggles to keep up with its own complex political continuity.

Oathes & Ashes is a visual novel that mostly plays to the genre's strength; there are a few additions to the formula, but by and large you’ll be reading dialogue and making choices. The game gets off to a rough start with a shaky tutorial. You’re playing as a set character, and not a protagonist of your own design. Alice is a snooty but capable Ventrue, the elite clan of vampires known as aristocrats and figures of authority. The Ventrue are one of the clans under the Camarilla, an ancient vampire society tasked with maintaining the masquerade and ensuring humans don’t discover the secret society in the shadows. You begin on a mission as Alice with a rival, with orders to extract a traitor from the Opera.

Immediately, Oaths & Ashes throws a lot at you: the terminology and lore of the setting, the parameters of your mission, and a difficult partner trying to keep you off balance. The game has a built-in codex, so you can check highlighted phrases in real-time to learn about the lore, but it’s still a bit overwhelming. I got softlocked after making a few bad choices; I would get a game over, return to my save, try again, and get a game over. I restarted and found the right path, but it was a frustrating start to the game and foreshadowed some of the problems I’d experience later.